Skip to content

September 30, 2013

2

Top 11 Domestic Airlines in America – and the survey says?

by Jason Dutton-Smith
Destination USA!

Are you travelling on a domestic flight in America soon? A recent survey by Consumer Reports asked over 16,600 subscribers to rank their favourite domestic US airlines to fly. There were a couple of clear winners while others didn’t fair so well. Here we have a look at the survey responses and give you some information on each airline.

Each participant was asked to rate the airline they had flown and mark them out of 100. The categories ranged from check-in services, baggage handling, seat comfort on-board, cabin crew, in-flight entertainment, food service and more.

Following is the order of each airline from best to worst, ranked on a scale of 0-100. Let’s have a look at the survey results.

1. Virgin America – 89/100

One of the youngest airlines in the U.S.A. beginning operations in 2007, Virgin America produced the highest marks of them all. A combination of a young fleet, groovy lighting, comfortable leather seats, cool cabin crew staff and one of the best entertainment systems in the air contributed to the high marks. But then again, you would not expect anything less from an airline under Sir Richard Branson’s Virgin umbrella. One of the great on-board service features is the ability to order food from your seat-back screen. Just swipe your credit card and it will be delivered to your seat. Having flown Virgin America a few times in both economy and First Class I can see why they have taken the main accolade of best domestic airline.
Website www.virginamerica.com

Virgin America in-flight

Virgin America in-flight

2. Southwest Airlines – 85/100

From humble beginnings as an intra-state airline in Texas to the largest Low Cost Carrier today, Southwest has stayed true to their no frills service and low fares philosophy and are one of the few airlines today that do not charge for the first two checked bags. With an all economy layout in the cabin, the leg room is still better than on most of the other major carriers. Their boarding process is rather different though with free seating once on-board (no seat assignments) and boarding is based on the time and sequence number from when you checked-in. Overall a worthy winner and one airline we have flown several times.
Website www.southwest.com

Southwest Airlines in-flight

Southwest Airlines in-flight

3. Jetblue Airways – 85/100

Another relative newcomer in the airline world is Jetblue. Founded in the late 1990’s, Jetblue is now a major U.S. carrier. Based at New York’s JFK airport with additional hubs in Boston, Orlando, San Juan and Long Beach, California, Jetblue is soon to move into the premium space with a business class cabin on coast to coast flights. Offering generous leg room for economy class and sporting an excellent entertainment system with DIRECTV cable stations beamed right to your seat, it’s no wonder that Jetblue is a popular choice.
Website www.jetblue.com

Jetblue in-flight

Jetblue in-flight

4. Hawaiian Airlines – 82/100

Hawaii’s home state airline offers domestic services throughout the Hawaiian Islands and 10 mainland U.S.A. destinations. Hawaiian’s international network now includes points in Asia, and many destinations in the South Pacific including Auckland, New Zealand as well as the Australian ports of Brisbane and Sydney. Hawaiian is always highly rated for their impressive on-time departure record and friendly aloha service. Hawaiian recently introduced stylish cabin interiors on their fleet of new Airbus A330s.
Website www.hawaiianairlines.com

Hawaiian Airlines 767-300

Hawaiian Airlines 767-300

5. Alaska Airlines – 81/100

Alaska is a full service carrier with a busy route network across the U.S. west coast, Alaska, Hawaii and Mexico and continues to expand throughout the Continental U.S. The airline is headquartered in Seattle and maintains a major presence in Los Angeles, San Francisco, Portland and Anchorage. Alaska is not part of any airline alliance but does have a code share agreement with American Airlines and several international carriers.
Website www.alaskaair.com

Alaska Airlines in-flight

Alaska Airlines in-flight


Hawaiian AirlinesiPads on 767 aircraft
Best and worstTop 10 best and worse airlines for safety
United Airlines upgrade – Service between Australia and USA receive an upgrade
10 longest flightsTop 10 longest flights from America


6. Frontier Airlines – 78/100

Based in Denver, Colorado this little airline has a big reputation. Self dubbed as ‘a whole new animal,’ Frontier sports different animal motifs on each of their aircraft tails. Facing stiff competition on their home turf in Denver, they have transformed into a low cost carrier but still offer DIRECTV cable entertainment on seat back screens, utilising the same technology as Jetblue. A nice ‘hometown airline’ with good service.
Website www.flyfrontier.com

Frontier Airlines animal tails

Frontier Airlines animal tails

7. Delta Airlines – 71/100

Delta is one of ‘the big four’ traditional major airlines (along with United, American and US Airways) and it beat out the other three mega-carriers in this survey. One of the largest airlines in the world today, Delta is a founding member of the Skyteam Alliance and has an extensive worldwide network. Delta also maintains a code share alliance with Virgin Australia. After their recent purchase of Northwest Airlines the merger formed an airline with an extensive Asian presence and a significant hub in Amsterdam. One area of the survey where Delta received bad marks was for the economy seat comfort – and one that we can personally attest to. While the seats are leather, the cushions are hard and uncomfortable. From an appearance stand point, the oddly coloured blue seats don’t do much to enhance the appearance of the cabin either. We’ve flown Delta several times this past year both domestic and international (LAX to Sydney) and aside the hard, unattractive seats, we were quite pleased with our Delta service, both on the ground and in the air.
Website www.delta.com

Delta Airlines 777 in-flight

Delta Airlines 777 in-flight

8. US Airways – 66/100

Mainly based on the east coast but with a large base in Phoenix, Arizona (thanks to the merger of US Airways and America West) they have a strong domestic route map including flights to Europe, Caribbean, Mexico and South America. US Airways ranked low in cabin cleanliness, seat comfort and entertainment and an inconsistent product between aircraft.
Website www.usairways.com

US Airways in-flight

US Airways in-flight

9. American Airlines – 66/100

One of the largest major airlines flying in America with their main base in Dallas, Texas, you can also reach most of the globe with American Airlines. Unfortunately this is another airline with an inconsistent product and ranked low on the cleanliness, entertainment and seating comfort. But they are embarking on a unification project to offer same product and service across the board and I have always enjoyed my flights with them. American Airlines and Qantas are each part of the Oneworld Alliance.
Website www.americanairlines.com

American Airlines in-flight

American Airlines in-flight

10. United Airlines – 63/100

United Airlines recently purchased Continental Airlines forming one of the largest carriers in the world. Like all mergers there will be teething problems and United suffers from inconsistent service and a mish-mash of airline interiors and products although it has been working hard of late to rectify this. Untied maintains a fleet of over 700 aircraft but work is well underway to standardise. The result once completed should bring a better product in each class. Again it seems the inconsistent product attributed to the rankings, especially around entertainment (Continental aircraft had seat back screens, United did not), cleanliness and seating comfort.
Website www.united.com

United Boeing 747-400

United Boeing 747-400

11. Spirit Airlines – 50/100

Based on the Ryanair low cost model of offering cheap airfares, Spirit is the air-fare add-on winner, charging extra for virtually everything, from making a booking over the phone to check-in and hefty baggage fees. Based in Fort Lauderdale, Florida and Dallas, Texas it serves mainly holiday and leisure destinations. The one thing with Spirit Airlines is you always know what you are getting….or not in this case. But even with the mountain of fees, the flights are still often cheaper than most of the major carriers. Relying on mass market you can always be assured of a great fare but be prepared for those sneaky fees. It’s a different model to what Australians are used to but provides a cheap way to get around the US.
Website www.spirit.com

Spirit Airlines in-flight

Spirit Airlines in-flight

One thing about travelling around America is it’s usually cheap and cheerful. Shopping around for the best fare will go a long way but just remember that most airlines, including the majors charge for checked bags. These fees are often cheaper if you book online and pay ahead of time.

Let us know your thoughts...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Note: HTML is allowed. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to comments

%d bloggers like this: